When I was a little girl, a family tradition my mother kept for years, was to prepare oyster stew each Christmas Eve. After eating our bowl of oyster stew, we then drove around our middle Georgia town looking at Christmas lights. Thinking back, I never remember eating an oyster! It was always the stew part of oyster stew that I loved. And, of course, the oyster crackers floating in my bowl that my grandfather would bring – this was his yearly contribution to the tradition! So, this year, I decided to give the tradition a try with my family – it was a success! Everyone loved it! With Buttercup(our family milk cow) giving 4 gallons of milk per day, it was also a great way to use up milk – I made a 2 1/2 gallon batch of oyster stew and every drop was eaten! While oysters are expensive, they are a nutritional powerhouse. Oysters are a good source of essential nutrients such as zinc, vitamin E, magnesium, potassium and high in omega-3 fatty acids which are great for you heart! Often in oyster stew, the oysters are left whole and you know they are done cooking when the edges curl. In the following recipe, I chopped the oysters to stretch them. Make sure to stir frequently, heat the milk slowly and not to allow the milk to boil.
Oyster Stew Recipe
Ingredients:
- 1/2 cup butter
- 1 small onion, grated
- 6 cups milk
- 1 pint oysters with liquor
- 1 cup cream
- 1 tsp sea salt (where to buy REAL salt)
- pepper to taste (where to buy spices)
Procedure:
In a large stock pot (or you may use a double boiler) saute the grated onion in butter.
Add the milk.
Next, add the oysters with liquor, cream, salt and pepper.
Heat the milk slowly, stirring often and do not allow it to boil.
If using whole oysters, the edges will curl when cooked. If using chopped oysters, the oysters will lose their shiny appearance and become darker in color.
Ladle into bowls and enjoy! Makes about 8 cups.
This post is part of: Homestead BarnHop, Not Baaad Sunday, Scrumptious Sunday, Sunday School, Sunday Showcase, Busy Monday, Marvelous Monday, Melt in Your Mouth Monday, Family Table, Fat Tuesday, Scratch Cookin’ Tuesday, Slightly Indulgent Tuesday, Traditional Tuesday, Allergy Free Wednesday, Healthy 2Day Wednesday, Party Wave, Real Food Wednesday, Wheat Free Wednesday, Foods Wednesday, Pinworthy, Creative Juice, Delightfully Inspiring Thursday, Frugal Days, Full Plate Thursday, Keep It Real Thursday, Pennywise Platter, Simple Lives Thursday, Thank Your Body Thursday, Thursday Treasures, Transformation Thursday, Fight Back Friday, Fresh Bites Friday, Gluten Free Friday, Whole Foods Friday














I’ve recently read that this is a Christmas tradition in many Amish & Menonite households..
I think it sounds yummy! I’ve made it in the past but added potatoes too. Either way… yum! Have a great day!
I never had a traditional oyster stew, but made my own very simple version, only with canned oysters. I’m the only one that will eat it in my household though. It’s just milk, butter, salt and cut up oysters with some of the juice. I so bet the REAL thing is Delicious!! I’ve actually been hungry for it lately, but some reason, the one store I buy the oysters at hasn’t carried them. Bummer!
Good Morning,
Your Oyster Stew looks delicious, we will just love it. Thank you so much for celebrating TWO YEARS with FULL PLATE THURSDAY, I appreciate your visit!
Come Back Soon
Miz Helen
My husband loves oyster stew but I’ve never made it. You recipe looks so simple and yummy I think I’ll give it a try. Visiting you from Full Plate Thursday.
I have never had oysters before! Or oyster stew
I do love clam chowder and this is similar to how I make that. I would love to have you link up with what i am eating! http://www.townsend-house.com/2013/01/what-i-am-eating-11.html
[...] raw, baked, boiled, grilled or fried, oysters are a nutritional powerhouse! I posted my recipe for oyster stew last week which will definitely become part of my menu planning. But, as I thought about the [...]
[...] Dina-Marie’s Oyester Stew! (Check out her other recipes too – they’re amazing! And she has an amazing family too!) [...]
[...] Oyster Stew from Cultured Palatte [...]